Embracing AI in Therapy: A New Era of Support and Understanding
A Little History
It’s Not an Either/Or Situation
Digging Deeper
What About Transference and Countertransference?
Co-Therapists?
Conclusion
Tips
Embracing AI in Therapy: A New Age of Co-Therapists
I recently recorded a podcast with my co-host, Lilian Borges, where we delved into the fascinating intersection of artificial intelligence and our profession. I must admit, I’ve only dabbled with ChatGPT and at times even forget it exists. However, in preparing for our discussion, I found myself intrigued by the current applications of AI in mental health and therapy.
A Little History
Let’s take a step back in time. Some of you may remember ELIZA, one of the first natural language programs developed in what would become MIT’s AI lab. Its creator, Joseph Weizenbaum, was taken aback when he realized that people began attributing emotions and thought processes to this rudimentary program. “I had not realized,” he reflected, “that extremely short exposures to a relatively simple computer program could induce powerful delusional thinking in quite normal people.” Surprisingly, some therapists utilized ELIZA as a prescreening tool and even combined its advice with their own therapeutic practices.
It’s Not an Either/Or Situation
Fast forward to 2025, and ChatGPT is light-years ahead of its predecessor, generating human-like responses that inspire users to feel a sense of connection. This phenomenon raises an essential question: If a chatbot can provide useful insights for free, why invest in a therapist?
This sentiment is understandable. In some cases, a chatbot may serve as a timely resource. I had a client grappling with interpersonal issues who turned to AI in the early hours of the morning. Instead of waking me, he sought advice from a chatbot, which provided him with effective strategies for self-regulation and communication—much to my relief!
Digging Deeper
Curiosity piqued, I probed the chatbot with questions frequently asked in my work with gay men. The responses were not only factual and relevant, but they closely mirrored the guidance I would typically offer. Remarkably, the chatbot encouraged my client to seek further exploration of his concerns with a therapist, offering both immediate comfort and a roadmap for his long-term mental health.
Can chatbots ever replace therapists? I think not. While AI can provide valuable information, it lacks the interpersonal experience that a qualified therapist offers. Studies consistently indicate that the therapeutic relationship itself—built on trust and empathy—is fundamental to healing.
Consider how you feel after a routine checkup with your medical provider. Just being in the presence of someone who cares about your health can instill a sense of confidence and reassurance. Similarly, the therapeutic relationship nurtures a deep connection that fosters emotional growth.
What About Transference and Countertransference?
In therapy, transference is a powerful tool, revealing a client’s past relationships and emotional patterns. Conversely, a therapist’s countertransference—rooted in their own experiences—can influence their reactions. Recognizing and accepting these dynamics is crucial in therapy.
Transference solidifies the bond between client and therapist during discussions of the past, creating intimate moments of insight and understanding. This level of connection cannot occur with a chatbot, which lacks the human capacity for empathy and the nuanced understanding of personal struggles.
Co-Therapists?
Surprisingly, I’ve found ChatGPT to be a valuable resource not just for me, but also for my clients and friends, despite my initial skepticism. I was particularly struck by its ability to provide helpful information, yet I urge caution: chatbots can sometimes “hallucinate,” sharing inaccuracies—much like when my author friend asked for book recommendations and was given non-existent titles.
One of my clients, a minister exploring AI, stumbled upon a chatbot and was amazed by the wealth of information available. He used that input as inspiration for a sermon and sought my opinion on the ethics of rephrasing it. I assured him that making the information his own was a commendable and ethical choice.
Conclusion
Truthfully, I’ve been learning how to navigate this technology effectively—often better than following those convoluted IKEA assembly instructions! If I can do it, so can you.
Embracing these advancements rather than resisting them can ultimately enrich our practice. People are asking critical questions about their relationships and receiving valuable insights, all without undermining the role of the therapist.
What’s not to like?
Tips for Engaging with AI in Therapy
- Use a Discerning Mind: If something seems off, it might be.
- Check Sources: Ensure your chatbot isn’t hallucinating.
- Enjoy a Non-Human Co-Therapist: Embrace the benefits of AI while encouraging users to seek professional mental health support.
As we continue to explore these frontiers, the collaboration between human therapists and AI can help cultivate a more informed and empowered clientele.