Exploring the New Integration: Photoshop in ChatGPT – A Photographer’s Perspective
Adobe Photoshop Meets ChatGPT: A New Era for Photo Editing?
As a professional photographer, I approached Adobe’s announcement about integrating Photoshop tools into ChatGPT with a mix of excitement and skepticism. While the prospect of quickly editing photos sounded appealing, I feared the implications of AI in my craft. Once I tested the integration, I was surprised—it brought both advantages and disadvantages I hadn’t anticipated.
Photoshop Inside ChatGPT: Not Generative AI
At first, I had visions of ChatGPT generating stunning visuals out of thin air. However, the integration acts more like a smart assistant than a creator. ChatGPT offers the ability to apply select Photoshop effects to photographs without generating new content. This distinction—agentic AI versus generative AI—is crucial. Adobe does not apply Content Credentials to these images, which is a notable difference when considering the ethics of AI-generated content.
While I appreciate AI aiding my workflow—like quickly masking subjects—I don’t want it to do the creative heavy lifting for me. Fortunately, this integration doesn’t remove the learning curve; it instead enhances it. For instance, as I edited my photo, ChatGPT provided explanations of terms like saturation and vibrance, ensuring new photographers still engage with the craft’s vocabulary.
Users Maintain Control
One significant feature of this tool is the sliders it provides, allowing users to control the intensity of the edits. This level of interaction keeps the user involved in the creative process, which is key for any artist.
When Terminology Goes Wrong
One downside of the integration is that AI can sometimes miss the mark. I was excited when ChatGPT mentioned applying a “Kodachrome look” to my image, only to be disappointed when I was provided with sliders for a tritone effect—two very different processes. Such inaccuracies can hinder the learning experience for those relying on AI for education.
A Lite Version of Photoshop
The current features offered through this ChatGPT integration feel more akin to Photoshop Elements. Users can adjust basic attributes like color, brightness, and contrast, and a few special effects like tritone and halftone can be applied. However, this lite version lacks many advanced capabilities that professional editors rely on. Limited to simpler adjustments, it doesn’t match up to the full-fledged Photoshop experience.
It’s also limited by ChatGPT’s payment tiers; as a free user, I could upload only one image per day, which ultimately frustrated my editing process.
Speed vs. Simplicity
In my experience, editing directly in Lightroom was significantly faster than using ChatGPT’s tools. The time spent uploading images and waiting for AI-generated adjustments ultimately made the process feel less efficient. The feature is still in its early stages, and I encountered glitches—like the tools being temporarily offline—which hampered my workflow.
The Future of Agentic AI in Photo Editing
AI is becoming increasingly integrated into photography workflows, but it’s crucial to discern where it adds value. I believe agentic AI can improve the industry by automating tedious, non-creative tasks like batch editing and creating Actions. It could serve as an advanced form of in-app guidance, though users should remain cautious of AI-driven inaccuracies.
At this stage, the integration of Photoshop into ChatGPT isn’t likely to replace extensive editing skills or advanced techniques. Instead, it offers a glimpse into the future of how people may learn and automate certain aspects of photo editing while still requiring engagement and understanding of the craft.
In summary, I’m relieved this isn’t merely a generative AI tool. While the integration has room for growth and precision, it ultimately may provide a gentle onboarding for those new to photography—without overshadowing the artistry involved.